TRENOS SiGINT - NZ PM's China Trip – A Trade Strategy Stuck in the Past Says Former Alibaba Exec

New Zealand’s recent trade delegation to China, led by Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, has triggered a wave of concern from across the business, innovation, and export communities. A now-viral LinkedIn thread by former Alibaba ANZ GM Pier Smulders revealed what many insiders have quietly known for years, that the country’s global trade strategy remains anchored in outdated paradigms.

Despite high-level participation, the mission was heavily criticised for being transactional, narrowly focused on short-term commodity sales, and lacking any meaningful representation from emerging industries like FoodTech, AI, or biomanufacturing. There was no sign of pioneering companies such as Daisy Lab or Opo Bio. Delegates skewed toward traditional players, while critical sectors like clean tech, regenerative food exports, and creative digital industries were entirely overlooked.

China, now a world leader in bio-economy infrastructure, synthetic protein, and e-commerce—is no longer merely a buyer of bulk exports. It is a co-creator of the global future. But New Zealand’s posture during this trip was one-dimensional, with PM statements focusing almost exclusively on what China could do for NZ, not what the two could build together.

The trip has exposed a growing disconnect between the forward-thinking Kiwi innovation sector and the political machinery still selling a milk-and-tourism model. Commenters across the LI thread called for a rese, one that includes SMEs, next-gen exporters, and cross-sector science and tech collaboration.

Human Factor

The frustration in the business community is visceral. The mission excluded many of the voices actively building NZ’s future food and tech exports. Innovators feel invisible. Consumers see a government stuck in a nostalgic loop. Meanwhile, the country risks missing the opportunity to redefine itself not just as a seller, but as a solutions partner in a decarbonising, tech-driven world.

TRENOS Metrics Snapshot

Metric	Description
Signal	Strategic Trade Misalignment
TikTok Views	N/A
Retail Footprint	Legacy-focused (milk, meat, education)
Ingredient Format	Animal-based commodity exports
Product Range	Limited; no regenerative or future-food presence
Consumer Segment	B2B institutional buyers, students
Brand Origin	NZ Government delegation
Export Status	Passive, sales-driven
Trend Classification	Innovation Deficit
System Pressure Point	Trade Monoculture Collapse

PFN News Story LINK